Sunday, November 15, 2026Independent · Sourced · Free to Read
Subscribe
Vetted News · Preparedness · History · Religion · And More

Proven Election Fraud: The Cases on the Record

From Tammany Hall and LBJ’s Box 13 to the voided 2018 North Carolina House race and Paterson, New Jersey’s 2020 mail election: documented fraud, and whether anyone was punished.

Election fraud is not a myth. It has changed results in America, sometimes for decades at a time. The cases below are documented by courts, official boards or the people involved. We note where people were prosecuted, and where they were not.

Historic cases

  • Tammany Hall, New York (1800s): The Democratic machine used “repeaters” who voted many times, fraudulent naturalizations and control of the count. Boss William Tweed was convicted in 1873 in connection with the machine’s looting of the city treasury and died in jail in 1878. Few were ever prosecuted for the vote fraud itself.
  • Hayes vs. Tilden (1876): Democrat Samuel Tilden won the popular vote, but 20 electoral votes were disputed amid fraud and violent voter intimidation, with charges against both parties. A 15-member Electoral Commission awarded all of them to Republican Rutherford B. Hayes by 8–7 party-line votes. No one was prosecuted.
  • Texas, “Box 13” (1948): Lyndon Johnson won the Democratic Senate runoff by 87 votes after Precinct 13 in Jim Wells County reported about 200 late votes, nearly all for him. In 1977, the precinct’s election judge, Luis Salas, told the Associated Press he had certified fraudulent votes. No one was prosecuted, and Johnson went on to the Senate and the presidency.
  • Chicago (1960): John F. Kennedy carried Illinois by fewer than 9,000 votes amid well-documented irregularities in Cook County. A special prosecutor charged hundreds of election workers; most charges were dismissed, and three workers were convicted and jailed. Historians still debate whether fraud changed the state’s result. Kennedy would have won the Electoral College without Illinois.

✅ Confirmed Scales icon Factual Lean note: Documented in court records, official histories and later admissions; whether fraud decided 1960 Illinois is still debated.

Recent cases

  • North Carolina’s 9th District (2018): The State Board of Elections unanimously voided the result of the U.S. House race and ordered a new election in February 2019, after evidence that operative Leslie McCrae Dowless ran an illegal absentee-ballot operation for the Republican candidate. Dowless was charged with state crimes, including illegal possession of absentee ballots and obstruction of justice, but died in 2022 before trial. Several people who worked for him were also charged.
  • Paterson, New Jersey (2020): In a city council election run by mail, roughly one in five ballots was disqualified, and a judge ordered a new election. The state attorney general charged a sitting councilman and the councilman-elect, among others, with election fraud. In 2026, both men’s indictments were dismissed, one over speedy-trial and evidence-disclosure problems (the state has appealed) and the other at prosecutors’ request, so neither was convicted.

✅ Confirmed Scales icon Factual Lean note: Official board order, court rulings and local reporting; the Paterson appeal was pending as of November 2026.

The Heritage Foundation database

The Heritage Foundation, a right-leaning think tank, keeps the most-cited list of proven cases: 1,619 as of its December 12, 2025 update, dating from 1982.

Horizontal bar chart of the 1,619 cases in the Heritage Foundation election fraud database by outcome: 1,381 criminal convictions, 138 diversion programs, 50 civil penalties, 25 judicial findings and 25 official findings.
What 1,619 proven fraud cases look like Source: The Heritage Foundation, Election Fraud Map, "Categories" page (last updated Dec. 12, 2025). Heritage calls it a sampling, not a complete count. Convictions = total minus other categories.
  • What it shows: Fraud happens in every kind of election, by every method: absentee-ballot fraud, impersonation, duplicate voting, false registrations, ineligible voting and official misconduct. Cases come from both parties.
  • Its limits, in Heritage’s own words: It calls the map “a sampling” of proven cases, not a complete count, and a list of proven cases by definition leaves out fraud that was never caught.
  • The other side’s reading: The left-leaning Brennan Center points out that 1,619 cases over four decades is tiny compared with the billions of votes cast. Both readings can be true: proven fraud is rare, and undetected fraud is, by definition, unmeasured.

✅ Confirmed Elephant icon Leans Right Lean note: Heritage’s counts are factual and sourced to court records; the database is compiled by a right-leaning group and its selection is not random.

Label key

  • ✅ Confirmed An official record, or two or more independent outlets, agree.
  • ❓ Unconfirmed Reported or claimed, but not yet independently verified.
  • ⚠️ Disputed Contradicted by the evidence or by credible sources, or actively contested.
  • Scales icon Factual Straight reporting that holds up across outlets on different sides.
  • Donkey icon Leans Left The facts hold, but the coverage tilts left: one-sided, loaded language, missing context or a single anonymous source.
  • Elephant icon Leans Right The facts hold, but the coverage tilts right: one-sided, loaded language, missing context or a single anonymous source.
  • Megaphone with hammer and sickle icon Likely Propaganda State-run or state-aligned media, a militant press office, a partisan campaign or group, or unverifiable spin.

Each story gets one confidence tag and one source-lean label, plus a one-line Lean note explaining the call. Every side is held to the same standard. More on how we cover the news.

Sources

Related on Candid Dragon